Dec 16 2010

Romanticism to Modernism 5

Published by Peter Schneck

Gravestone of John Hathorn, one of the Judges in the Salem Witch Craft Trials, and Nathaniel Hawthorne's Great-great-Grandfather

Gravestone of John Hathorn, one of the Judges in the Salem Witch Craft Trials, and Nathaniel Hawthorne's Great-great-Grandfather

Hawthorne’s story “Young Goodman Brown” (1835) is seen as a central and fairly typical example of his work in general.

This observation certainly pertains in regard to the story’s theme and major concerns, but also to the form in which these are presented and impressed on the reader.

Please read the story and try to answer some of the questions below (you may want to focus on some while only touching upon others).

  • How are the subjects of religion and faith treated in the story? Certainly, Hawthorne is making an argument about Puritan beliefs (especially the belief in good and evil), but do you see some more universal implications of his treatment of faith and belief?
  • What does the story tell us about the relation between the individual and his or her peers? Think about what we discussed in regard to the possible conflicts between individual and society (or collective) versus the need for social acceptance and recognition.
  • We also talked at length about the difference between the novel and the romance – a distinction that Hawthorne explicates in his preface to The House of the Seven Gables (1851). In what way does the short story also make use of the particular strategies of the romance (rather than the novel)? Obviously, Young Goodman Brown’s adventures in the forrest are decidedly more fantastic and supernatural than what happens to  Hester Prynne in The Scarlet Letter. But does that mean that the short story is simply dealing with the imagination / fancy? In what sense, do you think, can one read the story as the expression of some ‘higher truth’ – and what would that be? (For reference, you may want to look at the said preface and the way Hawthorne defines the novel and the romance – see below!)

You may download the story here: Young Goodman Brown.

And the ‘Preface to The House of the Seven Gables here: Preface.

If you treat all of these aspects in depth I am willing to consider this as the equivalent of two take home exams. If you stick to the two-page maximum shorter version this will count as one.

Please indicate in your e-mail which option you are taking, and also how many exams you have already handed in (including this one). If you have completed all your assignments, you may ask for a preliminary evaluation as to your final grade. This will give you the opportunity to ameliorate your performance by handing in another assignment should you desire to do so.

All the best for the holidays, and I am looking forward to seeing you all back in class in January!

4 responses so far

4 Responses to “Romanticism to Modernism 5”

  1. dollhouse miniatureon 29 Sep 2012 at 20:32

    I get this inquiry at every meeting. Thank you for setting the foundations so plainly.

  2. get a guitaron 27 Oct 2012 at 07:00

    That article was bland. Everyday living moves on.

  3. banc de binaryon 11 Apr 2013 at 21:17

    Excellent points altogether, you just gained a logo new reader. What may you suggest about your put up that you made some days ago? Any certain?

  4. To begin a prolonged story I had gotten having my hubby
    once i had been 15 and he was 7, without a doubt I’m sure it
    had been wrong in the age group feeling although this individual had been the initial man to show myself legitimate focus along with appreciate some other then your folks whom simply wished to sleep when camping.

    Therefore allows revisit realize, Im nineteen and possess
    some sort of 4 months older child currently along with my husband couldnt are more tired of people
    except if when he are looking for making love by himself.
    I needed our baby via Csection and the first thing he
    / she would as soon as they got household was sit down and
    also play dissertation writing are living definitely not be sure we all were being fine simply no they planned to participate in dissertation program reside.

    And now they simply just stays almost all his / her time smoking cigarettes cooking pot and hanging out with the close friends and also at the same time i’m being a solitary mother this feels as though.

    Previously impression that will newborn was born I’ve performed every thing to be sure
    she actually is wholesome along with pleased possesses everything the girl wants, I have become work and gotten two some other task
    presents and they has not elevated some sort of kids finger to perform whatever to aid us all.
    He has been 25 as well as I’m the main one submitting
    job apps pertaining to him or her, along with It’s my job to have our whole marriage when he decided not to possess a task I did along
    with at 16 My partner and i had been operating in addition to investing
    in their petrol and cigarettes while they lay close to and 4 carried out this whenever he seemed to be dismissed or even let go.

    As well as when he / she supports the newborn the lady
    yowls and he / she does not try and calm the girl he / she simply fingers the woman’s here we are at everyone
    and it also breaks or cracks our coronary heart since they have missed from connecting having
    the girl and also everyone all-around people can easily see that, the mums constantly
    wondering us the way you are accomplishing as well as brings up precisely how your
    lover can certainly tell i’m unhappy knowning that the child
    may feel that while i get unsatisfied or even burdened in addition to I do not might like to do that.

    your more painful part can be We have zero close friend in order to speak to in addition to
    he or she maintains stating he’s going to train us to drive
    rather than really does as well as im starting to feel like he or she
    should it and keep us stuck along with singled out, he / she are unable to discover precisely why internet
    marketing consequently unsatisfied dissertation writing but at any time My spouse and i make an effort to speak to him or her about this the response include things
    like sure, ok, positive, as well as the best I’m going to transform…
    I can not count the amount of periods she has claimed I will change along
    with do beneficial to a day and returned to help his
    / her shitty means. My spouse and i please don’t determine
    what i’m requesting and I am undecided exactly what more
    to express I can continue for hours about how exactly minor attention this individual
    shows throughout us plus the child but it could try to be an excessive amount of
    textual content writing dissertaton
    Seeing that enquired below My business is in fact at present
    coping with my own moms and dads while using child as well as he
    or she lifestyles regarding his father yet this individual hasn’t already in fact left my mom and dad
    but even so I have inquired in addition to our mothers and fathers
    hold inquiring how long he strategies with
    staying.

Trackback URI | Comments RSS

Leave a Reply